Welcome to Fisherman's Cove
Fisherman's Cove in Brooklyn offers a taste of the Caribbean with its diverse menu and welcoming atmosphere. Known for its oxtail stew, jerk chicken, and escovitch dishes, this restaurant promises a fulfilling dining experience. Customers praise the prompt service and friendly staff, making each visit enjoyable. The menu includes a variety of breakfast options, sandwiches, and traditional Caribbean dishes, satisfying every craving. With options for delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, Fisherman's Cove caters to all preferences. Whether you're a fan of West Indian cuisine or looking to try something new, Fisherman's Cove promises a flavorful journey through Caribbean flavors.
- 4 Newkirk Plz Brooklyn, NY 11226 Hotline: (718) 859-1580
Fisherman's Cove is a Caribbean gem located in the heart of Brooklyn, offering a plethora of options for both dining in and takeout. With a menu boasting many vegetarian choices and the convenience of delivery and reservations, this restaurant truly caters to all preferences. The classy yet casual ambiance, outdoor seating, and Wi-Fi access make it an ideal spot for a relaxed meal.
One standout feature of Fisherman's Cove is its diverse drink menu, including refreshing options like Limeade and Special Juice Carrot juice. The breakfast selection is equally enticing, with dishes like Calaloo and Salt Fish and Buttermilk Pancakes guaranteeing a satisfying start to your day. The Sandwiches section offers a variety of choices, from classic Bagel Sandwiches to hearty Bacon and Egg options.
Customer reviews praise the friendly staff, prompt service, and delicious offerings, with dishes like Jerk Chicken Meal and Oxtail Stew receiving high accolades. The attention to detail and quality ingredients shine through in each dish, leaving patrons coming back for more.
Fisherman's Cove is a must-visit for those craving authentic Caribbean flavors in a welcoming setting. Don't miss the chance to indulge in their mouthwatering dishes and experience a taste of the islands right in Brooklyn.

Such a pleasant experience every time. You know the "place where everybody knows your name"? Well they may not know your name, but they know your face. The food is good. Not wow greatest, but solid. I usually get the oxtail and white rice and have had the jerk chicken in the past. However, I must say, you get what you ask for. I ask for extra gravy, I get extra gravy. A small oxtail may look small, but it's filling. In the mood for a "it will taste great no matter what you order" dinner, this is the place where you will surely be satisfied. The staff has always been friendly, especially the guy who I engage in joking banter. Most notably, they are not slow like most Jamaican restaurants. In and out in a prompt manner. On my way home, this is a go-to for West Indian cuisine.

A native frequent flyer told me they have a saying- the snootier the establishment is, the better the food. Fisherman's def lives up to that quotable. It doesn't matter if there is no line and u are smiling like an idiot full of q & a's or if u r flashing bills- they don't give a hoot. Fisherman's are here to Only fulfill food orders, nothing more. So u better be clear and quick about what it is that you want. And get everything. I got the escovitch large dinner box and the large jerk chicken dinner. Luckily they were making new batches of everything and it was so worth the wait.

This review is long overdue, but my coworker and I used to eat this shit religiously for lunch. Mainly the Jerk Chicken Meal with rice and peas, oxtail gravy, plantains and cabbage with bbq sauce. The small size will get you satisfied but the medium will have you SI can't put it in words but this food really be RIGHT. The chicken is always juicy and the bbq sauce compliments it so well. I'm not gonna lie though very rarely the plantains are a hit or miss, most of the time they are so sweet and mushy, and very rarely they are super dry with no flavor. MAKE SURE U KNOW YOUR ORDER BEFORE YOU STEP UP TO THE CASHIER. They will literally suck their teeth at you, roll their eyes, and give you attitude because u don't know what u want. But can't blame them because how u gonna order food but u don't know what u want ? LOOK AT THE MENU.

Wow fisherman's cove never fails. Love their oxtail stews. It always hits the spot. Seasoned perfectly served with rice, salad or cabbage. I always say I want to try other dishes like the curry goat or the jerk chicken but always end up with the oxtail stew. I have heard of them selling out so maybe when I come no more oxtail it'll be my chance to try another dish.